The Wrong Kind of Silence
The village of Ashwick Parva prided itself on three things: its annual onion competition, its Norman church tower, and the Tuesday evening recitals of Gerald Huish, who had played the organ at St. Crispin’s for thirty-one unbroken years. When Gerald toppled sideways off his bench during the opening bars of a Handel voluntary, the entire congregation of eleven assumed it was his heart.
Dorothea Fenn, seated as always in the third pew on the left, assumed nothing of the sort.
She had taught English at Ashwick Primary for four decades, and in that time had developed an acute sensitivity to the difference between genuine accidents and engineered ones. Gerald Huish was sixty-two, walked four miles each morning, and had only last week beaten her nephew at tennis. She watched Dr. Pryce kneel beside the fallen man and noted the way Gerald’s breathing steadied almost immediately — shallow but rhythmic, like a man sleeping off something rather than suffering a cardiac episode.
“Stand back, please,” said Dr. Pryce, though he himself looked uncertain. “I believe it may be exhaustion.”
Dorothea said nothing. She was watching the organ loft.
While the others fussed, she climbed the narrow wooden stairs — her hip protested, as it always did — and stood at the instrument itself. The pipe organ at St. Crispin’s was elderly and temperamental, its bellows driven by an electric blower installed in the 1970s. The blower was silent now, switched off, and the air in the loft smelled faintly of something she couldn’t immediately name. Sweet, slightly chemical. Not candle wax. Not furniture polish.
She looked behind the instrument, into the narrow cavity where the blower motor sat. A small aerosol canister had been wedged between two pipes, its nozzle facing upward toward the bellows intake. It had clearly been empty for some time, but not forever.
Dorothea photographed it with her telephone, a skill her grandniece had insisted she learn.
—
Gerald recovered by Thursday, attributing the episode to a dizzy spell. But Dorothea paid him a visit that afternoon with a jar of her gooseberry preserve and a list of quiet questions.
“Who has keys to the organ loft?” she asked, setting two cups of tea on his kitchen table.
Gerald counted on his fingers. “Myself. Reverend Stanton. The cleaner, Mrs. Briggs. And young Callum, who pumps the manual bellows when the electric gives trouble.”
“Callum Tench?”
“The same. Good lad, though he’s been distracted lately.” Gerald paused. “Actually, now you ask — he rang me Monday evening to say he wouldn’t be available Tuesday. Which was odd, because I hadn’t asked him.”
Dorothea stirred her tea thoughtfully. “Was there anyone who might wish to see your recital interrupted?”
Gerald looked uncomfortable. “Dorothea, it was a dizzy spell—”
“The canister, Gerald. Behind the blower.”
He was quiet for a long moment. Then: “There’s been some unpleasantness about the new music programme. I’ve been leading the committee to bring in a professional director — outside hire, proper salary. Some people feel the budget should stay local.” He set down his cup. “Callum believed he was being considered for the role. He wasn’t. I should have told him directly, but I’m afraid I let it drift.”
—
Dorothea did not go to Constable Hewitt straight away. Hewitt was a well-meaning man who responded to problems the way a golden retriever responds to commands — enthusiastically, but with limited precision. She preferred to arrive with the picture already assembled.
She found Callum Tench at the village allotments, turning compost with unnecessary vigour. He was twenty-four, broad-shouldered, and deeply unhappy in the particular way of young men who believe the world has overlooked them.
“The aerosol contained isoflurane,” she said conversationally, settling onto a nearby bench. She had telephoned a former student who worked in veterinary pharmacy. “A sedative agent. Colourless, fast-acting if concentrated. The blower drew it straight through the bellows and up into the loft. Rather clever, in a grim sort of way.”
Callum said nothing. His spade continued to move.
“He could have been seriously hurt, you know. Elderly man, falling from a bench.”
“He’s not that old.” But the spade slowed.
“You’re not a cruel person, Callum. I taught you for two years. I remember your essay on the barn owl — you were the only child who wrote about what it must feel like to be one.” She let that sit. “I think you wanted the recital stopped, not Gerald harmed. Perhaps you hoped the disruption would cast doubt on his ability to manage the programme.”
The spade stopped entirely.
“It wasn’t fair,” he said finally, his voice cracking slightly at the edges. “I’ve been here. Playing, helping, learning every part of that instrument. He never even told me I wasn’t being considered. I had to hear it from Reverend Stanton in passing.”
“No,” Dorothea agreed. “That part wasn’t fair. Gerald knows it too.”
Callum looked at her then, for the first time.
“There are two ways forward,” she said. “One involves Constable Hewitt and a formal process that will follow you. The other involves your walking to Gerald Huish’s house this evening and having an honest conversation — and then coming forward with what you did, on your own terms, which reflects considerably better on a person’s character.” She stood, adjusting her coat. “Gerald is not an unkind man. He was simply careless with your feelings, which is a different thing altogether.”
—
Callum did walk to Gerald’s house that evening. What passed between them was private, though Gerald telephoned Dorothea at nine o’clock to say the conversation had been difficult and worthwhile in equal measure.
Constable Hewitt received a full account the following morning and consulted with the Crown Prosecution Service, who, given the circumstances and the absence of serious injury, took a measured view. Gerald declined to press charges, on the condition that Callum undertake a formal course in music programme administration at the county college — funded, quietly, from the parish arts budget.
At the following Tuesday’s recital, Dorothea sat in her usual pew. The organ sounded magnificent. And at the back of the church, half hidden behind a hymn book, Callum Tench listened with an expression that was not quite peace, but was moving, she thought, in that direction.
She allowed herself a small, private smile and turned the page.
Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links. If you click a link and make a purchase, Cozy Nook Tales may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. This helps support the site and allows us to continue publishing free stories every day.
