The Scarecrow That Stood Too Straight
The scarecrow had always leaned. That was the thing Agnes Pruett noticed first, standing at her kitchen window with a mug of tea going cold between her palms. She had looked out at Hadley’s field every morning for eleven years, and that battered figure of sacking and willow had always tilted to the left, like a man straining to hear something. This morning it stood perfectly upright.
She set down her mug.
The village of Thornfield woke slowly in October. Woodsmoke drifted across the lane, and the sycamores along the churchyard wall had shed enough leaves to carpet the verges in copper and brown. Agnes pulled on her mackintosh and her stout walking shoes, the ones with the scuffed toe she kept meaning to polish, and went out.
The field belonged to Colin Hadley. Forty acres of stubble and clay, bordered on the west by the land of his nearest neighbour, Douglas Fen. The two men had not spoken since the summer, when a disputed drainage ditch had ended in solicitors’ letters and a heated exchange at the post office that half the village had overheard.
Agnes walked the perimeter path. Up close, the scarecrow smelled of something unexpected beneath the familiar rot of old hessian: machine oil, faint and metallic. She looked at its base. The stake had been pulled from the ground and redriven. The soil around it was freshly disturbed, darker than the surrounding earth, and someone had made a poor job of tamping it down.
She crouched, her knees protesting, and looked across the low field toward Fen’s boundary hedge. A section near the old elm had been recently cut back. Thin, pale wood showed at the stems, not weathered at all.
She straightened and walked home for breakfast.
By eleven o’clock she had found a reason to visit Meredith Oakes, who ran the farm supplies shop on the high street and knew everything that moved through Thornfield before it had quite finished moving.
“Douglas Fen,” Agnes said, examining a packet of bulb fertiliser she had no intention of buying. “Has he been in recently?”
Meredith leaned on the counter. She was a compact woman with short grey hair and the habit of watching people very carefully before she answered them. “Tuesday. Bought a drum of gear oil and a set of long-handled loppers.”
Agnes replaced the fertiliser packet. “Did he.”
“Said he had machinery to service. Though his tractor went to Caldwell’s for repair three weeks ago and hasn’t come back.” Meredith paused. “He also asked whether we stocked cable ties. Heavy gauge ones. We didn’t, so I sent him to the builders’ merchant.”
Agnes thanked her and left.
She found Colin Hadley in his yard, pressure-washing mud from a trailer. He turned off the machine when he saw her, and the sudden silence made the rooks in the far elms sound very loud.
“Your scarecrow’s been moved,” Agnes said.
He stared at her. Water dripped from the trailer hitch and pooled in a tyre track. “What do you mean, moved?”
“I mean someone pulled the stake, shifted the position, and drove it back in. The soil is still loose. And there is something attached to the base, under the hessian skirt. I didn’t lift it to look, but I thought you might like to.”
He went very still in the way people do when they are working hard not to show something. Then he set down the pressure washer nozzle and walked quickly toward the field.
Agnes followed at a sensible pace.
Hadley lifted the scarecrow’s skirt of tied sacking. Beneath it, cable-tied to the stake, was a small weatherproof camera, the kind sold for watching wildlife. Its lens pointed directly at the drainage ditch along Fen’s boundary.
Hadley’s jaw tightened. “He’s documenting me. Trying to catch me interfering with the ditch so he has evidence for the solicitors.”
“Possibly,” Agnes said. “Or he has already been interfering with it himself, and he moved the scarecrow so the camera would face away from his side of the boundary and toward yours.”
Hadley looked at her. Then he looked at the camera. Then he looked at the elm and the freshly cut hedge stems, which gave a clear sightline from the ditch to the field.
“I want to see what’s on that,” he said.
“I would suggest you contact the police first,” Agnes said, “and let them retrieve it. If you handle it, you give his solicitor an argument.”
He stood for a moment with his hands on his hips, staring at the ditch. The wind moved through the stubble with a dry, papery sound. “I’ll ring them now.”
“Good.” Agnes turned to go. “And Colin. Lean the scarecrow back to the left when all this is done. It has always leaned. If you leave it straight, people will notice.”
He looked at her with an expression she had seen before on the faces of former pupils, a mixture of mild bewilderment and reluctant respect.
She walked home along the copper-carpeted lane. Her tea would need reheating. She put the kettle on and stood at the kitchen window, watching the field settle back into its ordinary quiet, the scarecrow listing gently now to the left, exactly as it always had.
Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links. If you click a link and make a purchase, Cozy Nook Tales may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. This helps support the site and allows us to continue publishing free stories every day.
Enjoyed this story? See our top 10 Village Detective picks.
