The Lapwing That Landed in December
The frost had taken hold of Nettleford overnight. It coated the lychgate in a white fur, stiffened the long grass around the older headstones, and made the gravel path crunch like broken biscuit under Agnes Peel’s boots. She had come, as she came every Thursday, to replace the small posy on her husband’s grave. Chrysanthemums this week, their papery petals the colour of clotted cream.
She was tying the twine when she heard the voices.
Two men, standing near the far wall where the yew tree threw its shadow across the oldest part of the churchyard. One was Gerald Finch, the estate agent from the village’s single high street. The other she did not immediately recognise. He wore a waxed jacket and carried a pair of binoculars, and he was pointing at the sky with the focused intensity of someone performing rather than looking.
“Lapwing,” the stranger said, loudly enough to carry. “Definitely a lapwing. Remarkable for this time of year.”
Agnes looked up. The sky above Nettleford was an unbroken pewter grey. Not a single bird crossed it.
She finished her knot and walked, unhurriedly, toward the gate.
Gerald Finch saw her and stiffened almost imperceptibly. He raised a hand. “Morning, Agnes.”
“Gerald.” She paused. “Thought I heard birdwatching.”
“My colleague from the county office,” Gerald said. “He’s keen.”
The colleague turned and offered a smile that did not involve his eyes. “Colin Marsh. Bird Society.” He patted the binoculars. “Spotted a lapwing just now. Unusual winter visitor.”
Agnes looked once more at the empty sky, then at the two men, then smiled pleasantly and walked on.
She mentioned it that afternoon to Reverend Sowerby, who was trimming the candle stubs in the nave and smelled of old wax and damp wool.
“Gerald Finch,” Sowerby repeated, setting down his knife. “He was in here last week as well. Measuring.”
“Measuring what?”
“The south transept. Said it was for heating quotes. But he had a fellow with him taking photographs.”
Agnes set her bag on the nearest pew. “The churchyard wall borders Linden Field.”
“It does.”
“And Linden Field has just been put up for outline planning permission.”
Sowerby turned to look at her properly.
“If a protected species is recorded using the churchyard as habitat,” Agnes said, “the planning authority would have to conduct an ecological survey before approving anything adjacent to it.”
“You think Gerald is trying to engineer a delay?”
“I think Gerald is representing the buyer, not the seller, and a delay of six months in the current market could significantly reduce the asking price.” She picked up her bag again. “I also think there was no lapwing.”
She walked to the village hall that evening where Dorothea Purse, who coordinated the local ramblers and kept meticulous records of every bird sighted in the parish since 1987, was stapling the February walk schedule to the noticeboard.
“Lapwing in the churchyard this morning,” Agnes said. “Gerald Finch’s friend saw one.”
Dorothea’s stapler paused mid-squeeze. “December lapwings don’t come this far inland. I’ve never recorded one in thirty-seven years.” She said it as though someone had suggested the vicar had taken up cage fighting.
“Would it be worth noting the absence in the record?”
Dorothea understood at once. She pulled out her log book, which had a faded robin on the cover and smelled of pencil shavings. “I’ll put a note in for this morning’s survey. Clear sky, no unusual visitors. I was up at first light, as always.”
“I know you were,” Agnes said. “I saw your light from the lane.”
Agnes wrote to the planning authority the following morning. Not an accusation. A careful, quietly worded letter, noting that an unverified sighting had been logged by a visitor to the churchyard on the fourteenth, that the parish’s independent observer had conducted her regular dawn survey and recorded nothing unusual, and that the authority might wish to consider the provenance of any ecological evidence submitted in connection with applications adjacent to the site.
She received an acknowledgement within a week. The ecological report submitted by the applicant’s agent, one Gerald Finch, was under review. The report’s sole witness had no verifiable record with the national Bird Society. The planning application was paused pending clarification.
Gerald did not come into the post office while Agnes was there for the remainder of that month. When they finally met at the Christmas market in the village square, between a stall selling fudge and one selling wreaths of dried orange and cinnamon, he looked at her for a long moment over a paper cup of mulled wine.
“Remarkable things, birds,” he said at last.
“They are,” Agnes agreed. “Particularly the ones that don’t exist.”
She bought a wreath of dried orange and cinnamon, and walked home through the frost, and the gravel on the churchyard path crunched exactly as it had that morning two weeks ago, when she had first looked up at an empty sky and known something was wrong.
Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links. If you click a link and make a purchase, Cozy Nook Tales may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. This helps support the site and allows us to continue publishing free stories every day.
Enjoyed this story? See our top 10 Village Detective picks.
